Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches, crafted in Richmond, Virginia, have become a favorite for dessert lovers. Founded in 2017 by Hannah Pollack and Xavier Meers, this women- and veteran-owned brand blends Southern flavors with European-style craftsmanship. Their premium treats are now sold in over 2,400 stores, including Costco and Kroger.
Each sandwich features rich, 14% butterfat ice cream nestled between freshly baked, chewy cookies. Flavors like Strawberry Shortcake and Banana Pudding evoke nostalgia while delivering gourmet quality. Customer reviews praise the creamy texture and creative flavor profiles.
This article explores Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches reviews, diving into their taste, quality, and appeal. From viral social media buzz to in-store experiences, we’ll cover what makes them stand out. Let’s dig into why these treats are a must-try for ice cream fans.
The Story of Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches
Nightingale began in 2017, inspired by Southern desserts like Key Lime Pie. Founders Hannah and Xavier aimed to elevate the classic ice cream sandwich with premium ingredients. Their handcrafted approach quickly gained traction in Richmond.
By 2025, Nightingale expanded to major retailers like Costco, Kroger, and The Fresh Market. Their viral Cookie Monster flavor sold out in a week at Costco in 2024. Reviews highlight their growth as a testament to quality.
The brand’s women- and veteran-owned status adds to its appeal. Features in Fast Company and Southern Living boost its reputation. Nightingale combines nostalgia with sophistication in every bite.
What Makes Nightingale Stand Out
Nightingale uses high-quality, non-GMO ingredients, including 14% butterfat ice cream. This creates a creamy, rich texture that customers love. The cookies, baked fresh, are soft and chewy, never hard.
Flavors like Chocolate Blackout and Strawberry Shortcake offer bold, Southern-inspired tastes. Reviewers appreciate the real fruit and cookie crumbs used, avoiding artificial flavors. All products are nut-free, catering to allergy-conscious consumers.
The “chomp-sized” mini sandwiches, exclusive to Costco, make sharing easy. Their vibrant packaging and unique flavors spark excitement. Nightingale’s attention to detail sets it apart from mass-produced brands.
Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches Reviews: What Customers Love
Customer reviews for Nightingale average 4.7 stars across platforms like Amazon and Yelp. Fans rave about the creamy ice cream and soft cookies, especially in Strawberry Shortcake and Cookie Monster. A TikTok user called them a “Costco jackpot” for their quality.
The Strawberry Shortcake flavor, with its brown sugar cookies, earns high praise for its fresh berry taste. Reviewers on Food & Wine describe it as “perfect for summer afternoons.” Banana Pudding also wins for its nostalgic Nilla Wafer-like biscuits.
Some note the $19.99 price for an 18-pack at Costco is steep but worth it. Others mention limited availability in some regions. Overall, the indulgent texture and flavors keep customers hooked.
Top Flavors to Try
Nightingale’s lineup includes classic and creative flavors. Here are some favorites based on reviews:
- Strawberry Shortcake: Creamy strawberry ice cream between brown sugar cookies. Fans love its fresh, summery taste.
- Cookie Monster: Vanilla ice cream with cookie crumbs, sandwiched by chocolate chip cookies. It’s a kid-friendly hit.
- Banana Pudding: Banana ice cream with Nilla Wafer-like biscuits. Reviewers call it rich yet balanced.
- Chocolate Blackout: Chocolate ice cream with cake pieces and frosting swirl. Chocolate lovers praise its decadence.
Seasonal flavors like Gingerbread Caramel add variety. Customers check Nightingale’s website for new releases. These flavors showcase the brand’s Southern flair.
Comparing Popular Flavors
Here’s a table comparing three top Nightingale flavors based on customer feedback:
| Flavor | Key Features | Customer Feedback |
|---|---|---|
| Strawberry Shortcake | Strawberry ice cream, brown sugar cookies | “Fresh and creamy, perfect summer treat.” |
| Cookie Monster | Vanilla ice cream, chocolate chip cookies | “Fun and nostalgic, kids love it.” |
| Chocolate Blackout | Chocolate ice cream, cake pieces, swirl | “Decadent, a chocolate lover’s dream.” |
This table highlights the variety of Nightingale’s offerings. Strawberry Shortcake is refreshing, while Chocolate Blackout is indulgent. Reviewers suggest sharing chomp-sized sandwiches for variety.
The Ice Cream Sandwich Experience
Nightingale’s ice cream sandwiches are known for their rich, creamy texture. The 14% butterfat ice cream stays soft, making every bite smooth. Customers describe it as “luxurious” compared to standard brands.
The cookies are a standout, baked fresh to complement each flavor. Reviewers on Sweety High note the brownie-like texture of Chocolate Blackout’s cookies. The balance of cookie and ice cream is perfect.
Fans love the portion size, with full sandwiches at 2.6 ounces and minis for lighter snacking. The nut-free recipe ensures accessibility. It’s a treat that feels both homemade and gourmet.
Where to Find Nightingale Sandwiches
Nightingale is sold at Costco, Kroger, The Fresh Market, and other retailers. The Costco-exclusive 18-pack of chomp-sized Strawberry Shortcake costs around $19.99, or $1.11 per sandwich. Four-packs, priced at $7–$9, are available at smaller stores.
The brand’s website offers a store locator for easy access. Online reviews mention checking stock, as popular flavors sell out fast. Bulk buying at Costco is a fan favorite for value.
Instagram posts from @nightingaleicecream highlight new flavors and store events. The Strawberry Shortcake flavor is currently limited to Northeast Costco stores. Fans are encouraged to request it at local retailers.
Tips for Enjoying Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches
Let sandwiches sit for a few minutes before eating for optimal texture. Reviewers suggest this for a softer, creamier bite. Store them in the freezer’s back to maintain freshness.
Pair flavors like Banana Pudding with coffee for a cozy treat. Customers love serving Strawberry Shortcake at summer gatherings. The minis are perfect for parties or kids’ snacks.
Check Nightingale’s social media for seasonal flavors like Pumpkin Jack o’ Lantern. Buying in bulk at Costco saves money, as noted in reviews. Stock up before popular flavors sell out.
Social Media and Online Buzz
Nightingale thrives on TikTok, with users like @cleankitchennutrition rating Strawberry Shortcake a “10 out of 10.” Videos showcase the vibrant cookies and creamy ice cream. Instagram posts highlight the homestyle brown paper packaging.
On X, fans celebrate finding Nightingale at Costco, calling it “life-changing.” Posts praise the Cookie Monster flavor for its nostalgic appeal. The brand’s viral moments boost its popularity.
Yelp and Amazon reviews average 4.6–4.7 stars, with over 1,000 ratings. Some note limited regional availability, but most love the quality. The online buzz keeps Nightingale trending.
Why Nightingale Stands Out
Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches blend Southern nostalgia with premium craftsmanship. Their high butterfat ice cream and fresh cookies deliver unmatched quality. Reviewers call them a step above typical frozen treats.
The creative flavors, like Key Lime Pie and Miso Churros, spark excitement. The nut-free, non-GMO ingredients cater to health-conscious eaters. Customers see it as a guilt-free indulgence.
With availability at major retailers and a growing fanbase, Nightingale is accessible yet exclusive. Its women- and veteran-owned story adds heart. Reviews urge dessert lovers to try it.
Summary
Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches, founded in Richmond, Virginia, are celebrated for their rich, 14% butterfat ice cream and chewy cookies. Reviews, averaging 4.7 stars, praise flavors like Strawberry Shortcake, Cookie Monster, and Chocolate Blackout for their creamy texture and Southern-inspired taste. Sold at Costco, Kroger, and The Fresh Market, the brand’s nut-free, non-GMO treats appeal to many. Despite a premium price, fans say the quality is worth it. Nightingale’s viral buzz and artisanal approach make it a must-try dessert.
FAQ
What are the best Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwich flavors?
Strawberry Shortcake, Cookie Monster, and Chocolate Blackout are top picks. Reviewers love Strawberry’s fresh taste and Cookie Monster’s nostalgic vibe. Seasonal flavors like Gingerbread Caramel also shine.
Where can I buy Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches?
They’re available at Costco, Kroger, and The Fresh Market. Costco offers an 18-pack of chomp-sized Strawberry Shortcake for $19.99. Check the brand’s website for a store locator.
Are Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches allergy-friendly?
Yes, all sandwiches are nut-free and made with non-GMO ingredients. Reviewers with allergies appreciate the clean-label approach. Always check packaging for specific allergens.
Why are Nightingale sandwiches so popular?
Their 14% butterfat ice cream and fresh cookies create a creamy, indulgent texture. Unique flavors like Banana Pudding evoke nostalgia. Fans say the quality justifies the price.