Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, is a paradise for beach lovers and dessert enthusiasts. Among its many attractions, the island boasts a vibrant ice cream scene that draws locals and tourists alike. From creamy classics to unique flavors, there’s a scoop for every taste.
The warm coastal climate makes ice cream a perfect treat after a day at the beach. Shops across the island offer homemade scoops, artisanal gelato, and refreshing sorbets. Each spot brings its own charm, making them must-visit destinations.
This guide dives into the best ice cream on Hilton Head Island, highlighting top shops, flavors, and tips for visitors. With recent reviews and local insights, you’ll find the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth. Let’s explore the sweetest spots on the island!
Why Hilton Head Is a Haven for Ice Cream Lovers
Hilton Head’s sunny beaches and laid-back vibe pair perfectly with frozen treats. Ice cream shops here thrive on creativity, offering unique flavors and high-quality ingredients. This ensures a delightful experience for every visitor.
Many shops are family-owned, adding a personal touch to their offerings. From classic vanilla to adventurous blends, the variety is impressive. Locals and tourists alike rave about the generous portions and friendly service.
The island’s tourism fuels a competitive dessert scene. Shops strive to stand out with fresh, homemade ice cream and inviting atmospheres. This dedication makes Hilton Head a top spot for ice cream enthusiasts.
Top Ice Cream Shops on Hilton Head Island
Hilton Head Ice Cream, located at 55 New Orleans Rd, is a local institution since 1982. Known for homemade flavors like Cookie Monster and Peach Pecan, it boasts a 4.3/5 rating from 614 Tripadvisor reviews. The shop draws crowds with its creamy, award-winning scoops.
The Ice Cream Cone in Coligny Plaza, open since 1971, offers over 78 flavors. Favorites like Blueberry Cheesecake and Peanut Butter Cookie Dough are served in homemade waffle cones. It has a 4.5/5 Yelp rating for its nostalgic vibe and generous portions.
The Frozen Moo, also in Coligny Plaza, features 92 flavors of ice cream, frozen yogurt, and sorbet. Its lineless payment system speeds up service, earning a 4.5/5 Tripadvisor score. Unique options like Banana Cream Pie make it a family favorite.
Best Ice Cream on Hilton Head Island
To answer the question, “What is the best ice cream on Hilton Head Island?” Hilton Head Ice Cream stands out for its homemade quality and variety. With a 4.3/5 Tripadvisor rating and the 2022 Travelers’ Choice award, it offers flavors like Chocolate Cayenne, priced at $4–$6 per scoop. A 2025 review praises its “huge servings” and “rich texture.”
The Ice Cream Cone is a close contender, especially for its nostalgic charm and 78+ flavors. Its Key Lime Pie scoop, lauded in a June 2023 Tripadvisor review, costs $4.50 for a medium cone. Yelp users give it 4.5/5 for its friendly service and vegan options like Dole Whip.
The Salty Dog Ice Cream Shop at South Beach Marina is a reader favorite, per a 2025 Island Packet poll, with a 4.5/5 Google rating. Its Key Lime Pie flavor, priced at $5, is a hit for its creamy consistency and waterfront views. Each shop offers a unique experience, perfect for different tastes.
Unique Flavors to Try
Hilton Head Ice Cream’s Cookie Monster is a vibrant blue treat with cookie dough bits. It’s a kid-friendly favorite with a playful look. A 2023 Yelp review calls it “a must-try for families.”
The Frozen Moo’s Pralines and Cream blends sweet caramel with crunchy pecans. This Southern-inspired flavor is a crowd-pleaser. Tripadvisor reviewers in 2023 praise its “authentic taste” at $4.50 per scoop.
The Ice Cream Cone offers Green Tea ice cream for a unique, earthy flavor. It’s a refreshing choice for adventurous eaters. A 2025 Yelp review highlights its “smooth, bold taste.”
Vegan and Dairy-Free Options
Vegan and dairy-free ice cream options are plentiful on Hilton Head. The Ice Cream Cone serves Dole Whip in pineapple and strawberry, perfect for vegans. These cost $4–$5 and are praised for their creamy texture.
Hilton Head Ice Cream offers dairy-free sorbets, like mango, made with real fruit. These are gluten-free and have a 4.5/5 rating for freshness. A 2023 review notes their “vibrant fruit flavor.”
The Frozen Moo provides no-sugar-added and dairy-free options, like coconut sorbet. Priced at $4.50, they cater to dietary needs. Yelp reviews commend their inclusivity and taste.
Comparison of Top Ice Cream Shops
Here’s a table comparing three top ice cream shops on Hilton Head Island:
| Shop Name | Key Features | Price (Approx.) |
|---|---|---|
| Hilton Head Ice Cream | Homemade, 40+ flavors, award-winning | $4–$6 (scoop) |
| The Ice Cream Cone | 78+ flavors, vegan Dole Whip, nostalgic | $4–$5.50 (scoop) |
| The Frozen Moo | 92 flavors, lineless system, family-owned | $4.50–$6 (scoop) |
This table showcases the diversity of Hilton Head’s ice cream scene. Hilton Head Ice Cream excels in quality, The Ice Cream Cone offers nostalgia, and The Frozen Moo provides variety. Choose based on your flavor and vibe preferences.
Tips for Enjoying Ice Cream on Hilton Head
Visit during off-peak hours, like late morning, to avoid summer crowds. Shops like The Frozen Moo can have lines out the door in peak season. Early visits ensure shorter waits.
Bring cash for smaller shops, as some, like The Frozen Moo, may charge a credit card fee. A 2023 Tripadvisor review notes their cash preference. This saves on surcharges.
Check social media for seasonal flavors or deals. Hilton Head Ice Cream offers custom orders with 48-hour notice, per their website. Follow shops on X for updates.
Ice Cream Shops Near Popular Attractions
Many ice cream shops are near Hilton Head’s top spots. The Ice Cream Cone and The Frozen Moo are in Coligny Plaza, a short walk from Coligny Beach. This makes them perfect post-beach stops.
The Salty Dog Ice Cream Shop is at South Beach Marina, near Sea Pines Forest Preserve. Its waterfront location adds scenic charm. A 2025 Google review praises its “perfect sunset dessert spot.”
Kilwins in Shelter Cove, close to Shelter Cove Harbour, offers ice cream and fudge. Its 40+ flavors, like Macadamia Nut, are ideal after shopping. It has a 4.2/5 Yelp rating.
Family-Friendly Ice Cream Experiences
Hilton Head’s ice cream shops cater to families with fun vibes. The Frozen Moo’s cow statue and mural delight kids, per a 2023 Tripadvisor review. Its 92 flavors keep everyone happy.
The Ice Cream Cone offers kid-friendly options like Cookie Monster and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches. These cost $5–$6 and are a hit with young visitors. Yelp reviews note the “welcoming atmosphere.”
The Salty Dog provides outdoor seating with marina views, perfect for family outings. Their ice cream sandwiches are a favorite for $5.50. A 2025 review calls it “family-friendly perfection.”
Recent Customer Feedback
Recent reviews highlight Hilton Head Ice Cream’s quality but note occasional service issues. A 2025 Yelp review complains of a rude employee closing early, though flavors like Chocolate Fudge were praised. Most give it 4.3/5 for taste.
The Ice Cream Cone earns consistent praise for its large portions. A July 2025 Yelp review raves about the Key Lime Pie scoop, calling it “so creamy.” It maintains a 4.5/5 rating.
The Frozen Moo’s lineless system is a hit, per a June 2023 Tripadvisor review. Customers love the Butter Pecan sundae for $6. Service and variety keep its 4.5/5 rating strong.
Summary
Hilton Head Island is a dessert lover’s paradise, with top ice cream shops like Hilton Head Ice Cream, The Ice Cream Cone, and The Frozen Moo leading the way. These spots offer homemade scoops, vegan options, and unique flavors like Cookie Monster and Pralines and Cream. Whether near Coligny Beach or South Beach Marina, they deliver creamy delights with nostalgic charm. Perfect for families or solo treats, these shops make every visit sweet. Explore Hilton Head’s ice cream scene in 2025 for a delicious island experience!
FAQ
What are the best ice cream shops on Hilton Head Island?
Hilton Head Ice Cream, The Ice Cream Cone, and The Frozen Moo are top picks. They offer homemade flavors and vegan options, with 4.3–4.5/5 ratings. Find them at Coligny Plaza or New Orleans Rd.
Are there vegan ice cream options on Hilton Head?
Yes, The Ice Cream Cone offers Dole Whip in pineapple and strawberry for $4–$5. The Frozen Moo has dairy-free sorbets like coconut. Hilton Head Ice Cream provides mango sorbet.
What unique flavors should I try?
Try Cookie Monster at Hilton Head Ice Cream or Pralines and Cream at The Frozen Moo. The Ice Cream Cone’s Green Tea is a bold choice. Each costs $4–$6 per scoop.
Where can I find ice cream near Coligny Beach?
The Ice Cream Cone and The Frozen Moo in Coligny Plaza are steps from the beach. Both offer 78–92 flavors for $4–$6. They’re perfect post-beach stops.
How do I avoid long lines at ice cream shops?
Visit in late morning or early afternoon to beat summer crowds. The Frozen Moo’s lineless system speeds up service. Check shop hours on Yelp or their websites.