Cookie cakes blend the chewy goodness of cookies with cake-like size and decoration. Often made from chocolate chip dough, they feature frosting messages and borders. Perfect for birthdays or gatherings, they serve crowds easily.
Chains and bakeries offer custom designs with short notice. Grocery stores provide affordable ready-made options. Online shipping brings gourmet versions nationwide.
Many prefer them over traditional cakes for casual fun. Flavors and toppings add variety.
History of Cookie Cakes
Cookie cakes gained fame in the late 1970s through Great American Cookies. Founders Michael Coles and Arthur Karp opened the first store in 1977 in Atlanta. They used a family chocolate chip recipe for large, decorated versions.
Mall locations boosted popularity with impulse buys. Custom icing made them ideal for celebrations. The concept spread quickly across the U.S.
Earlier cookie-like treats existed, but the modern frosted giant emerged then. Today, chains and independents continue the tradition.
Popular Cookie Cake Flavors
Chocolate chip remains the classic base with vanilla or chocolate frosting. Custom messages and colors personalize them. Add sprinkles or candies for extra flair.
Other options include:
- Double chocolate – Rich cocoa dough and frosting.
- Funfetti – Vanilla with colorful sprinkles.
- Peanut butter – Nutty base with chocolate accents.
- Sugar cookie – Buttery with bright icing.
- Red velvet – Tangy twist with cream cheese notes.
Seasonal designs feature holidays or themes. Some spots offer M&M or Oreo mix-ins.
Where to Buy Cookie Cake?
Cookie cakes appear at mall chains, grocery bakeries, and online shippers. Great American Cookies leads with custom orders in stores or online. Walmart and Publix stock affordable versions in bakery sections.
Mrs. Fields ships personalized 12-inch cakes nationwide. Goldbelly partners with bakeries for gourmet delivery. Local spots provide fresh daily options.
In 2026, availability stays strong with seasonal promotions. Check store locators for nearest spots.
Top Places to Buy Cookie Cakes
| Place/Chain | Common Sizes and Flavors | Notes and Availability |
|---|---|---|
| Great American Cookies | 12-16 inch, chocolate chip custom | Mall locations, online ordering |
| Mrs. Fields | 12-inch custom chocolate chip | Nationwide shipping, personalized |
| Walmart | Square or round, chocolate chunk | Bakery section, affordable packs |
| Publix | Decorated rounds, custom messages | Southeast strong, in-store pickup |
| Costco | Large sheets occasionally | Bulk sizes, seasonal |
| Cookies by Design | Gourmet decorated | Delivery focused |
| The Great Cookie | 13-inch custom | Online shipping nationwide |
| Goldbelly Partners | Giant from various bakeries | Premium, shipped fresh |
| Local Bakeries | Varied flavors like funfetti | Fresh, custom designs |
Prices range from $10 at groceries to $50 shipped gourmet. Custom adds cost but fun.
Many offer pickup or local delivery.
Buying at Chains and Malls
Great American Cookies excels in mall settings with fresh baking. Order in person or online for pickup. Designs suit any occasion.
Mrs. Fields stores provide similar custom experiences. Chains ensure consistent quality.
Visit food courts for quick slices. Full cakes need short advance notice.
Grocery Store Options
Walmart bakery offers square message cakes cheaply. Publix allows online ordering for pickup. Costco occasionally stocks large ones.
Look in display cases or ask for custom. Affordable for casual needs.
Evening visits catch fresh stock. Sales lower prices further.
Online Shipping and Delivery
Mrs. Fields and The Great Cookie ship nationwide. Goldbelly features artisanal giants. Cookies by Design focuses on delivery.
Careful packing keeps them fresh. Ideal for gifts or distant celebrations.
Apps like Instacart bring local chain cakes fast.
Tips for Choosing and Enjoying
Pick based on group size and occasion. Chocolate chip suits most tastes. Add personal messages for impact.
Store at room temperature briefly or refrigerate. Serve with ice cream for extra treat.
Order ahead for busy times. Share slices for parties.
Summary
Cookie cakes combine cookie chew with cake convenience and decoration. Find classics at Great American Cookies or groceries like Walmart and Publix. Online options from Mrs. Fields and Goldbelly deliver anywhere.
History ties to 1970s mall innovation with lasting appeal. Flavors focus on chocolate chip but vary. Enjoy for birthdays or anytime indulgence.
FAQ
Who invented the cookie cake?
Great American Cookies founders Michael Coles and Arthur Karp popularized it in 1977. They created large, decorated chocolate chip versions in malls.
What is the most popular cookie cake flavor?
Chocolate chip with vanilla frosting leads. Custom decorations make it versatile for occasions.
Can I get a cookie cake delivered nationwide?
Yes, Mrs. Fields, Goldbelly, and The Great Cookie ship fresh ones. Local apps handle chain delivery.
Do grocery stores like Walmart sell cookie cakes?
Yes, Walmart offers affordable square or round versions in bakery. Publix provides custom pickup too.