Turkey Hill Ice Cream Review 2025

Turkey Hill Ice Cream, a Pennsylvania favorite since 1931, is known for its creamy textures and diverse flavors. This family-owned brand has grown from a small dairy to a national name. In 2025, its new Late Night collection has sparked fresh excitement.

With over 50 flavors, Turkey Hill offers something for every dessert lover. From classic Vanilla to bold picks like Buttery Southern Pecan Pie, the lineup is vast. This article explores customer reviews, top flavors, and what makes Turkey Hill stand out.

Whether you’re stocking your freezer or craving a sweet treat, Turkey Hill is a go-to. We’ll dive into taste, texture, and value based on real feedback. Read on to see if Turkey Hill deserves a spot in your cart.

What Is Turkey Hill Ice Cream?

Turkey Hill began as a small dairy in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Founded by Armor Frey, it started making ice cream in the 1950s. Today, it’s still family-owned, using local milk and cream for freshness.

The brand boasts over 50 flavors, including premium pints and classic quarts. Its 2025 Late Night collection introduced seven indulgent flavors like Ultimate Cookie Overload. Turkey Hill also offers frozen yogurt, sherbets, and ice cream bars.

Known for affordability, Turkey Hill is sold at retailers like Walmart and Kroger. Its commitment to local sourcing and conservation, like the Clean Water Partnership, adds to its appeal.

Why Choose Turkey Hill?

Turkey Hill combines quality with budget-friendly prices. Its ice cream is creamier than generic brands but more affordable than premium ones like Häagen-Dazs. This balance makes it a popular freezer staple.

The 2025 Late Night collection targets indulgent snacking with bold mix-ins. Flavors like Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate Espresso cater to adventurous tastes. The brand also offers no-sugar-added and lighter options for diverse diets.

Turkey Hill’s wide availability is a plus. You can find it in grocery stores nationwide or at their Pennsylvania mini-marts. The variety and value keep customers coming back.

Turkey Hill Ice Cream Review: What Are People Saying?

Turkey Hill gets mixed but mostly positive feedback in 2025. On Walmart.com, flavors like Cookies ‘n Cream score 4.5 out of 5 from over 100 reviews. Fans praise the smooth texture and creative combinations.

X posts highlight the Late Night lineup, with Brownie Batter Cookie Dough earning buzz. Some call it “genuinely pleasant” with a great cookie-to-ice-cream ratio. However, reviews on ComplaintsBoard.com show a 1.1-star rating from 135 users, citing issues like missing ingredients.

Negative feedback often focuses on inconsistent mix-ins or icy textures. Some report containers not being fully filled. Overall, fans love the affordability and variety, but quality can vary.

Top Flavors in 2025

Turkey Hill’s 2025 lineup includes classics and bold new additions. Customer reviews point to a few favorites that stand out. Here’s a list of top picks:

• Cookies ‘n Cream: Vanilla ice cream with chocolate cookie crumbles, a party favorite.
• Buttery Southern Pecan Pie: Butter pecan with caramel swirls and pie crust pieces.
• Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate Espresso: Mocha base with chocolate chips and caramel.
• Cherry Chocolate Chunk: Cherry ice cream with real fruit and chocolate flakes.

Limited-edition flavors like Barbie-inspired options are also popular. Some find classics like Vanilla too plain or sweet. The Late Night collection gets praise for its indulgent mix-ins.

Nutritional Breakdown

Turkey Hill’s ice cream varies in calories based on flavor. A 2/3-cup serving ranges from 150–250 calories, with richer flavors on the higher end. Fat content reflects the use of real cream.

No-sugar-added options, like Vanilla, are available for lighter diets. Allergen info is on the website, but cross-contamination is possible. Check labels for dietary needs.

Taste and Texture: How Does It Compare?

Turkey Hill’s texture is smooth and creamy for most flavors. Reviewers note it’s better than budget brands but not as dense as premium ones like Talenti. The Late Night pints feel slightly heavier.

Flavors like Cookies ‘n Cream deliver a balanced taste with crunchy mix-ins. The Southern Pecan Pie offers a buttery, rich profile. Some report an icy texture if not thawed properly.

Mix-ins are decent but conservative, per reviews. You won’t find huge chunks like in Ben & Jerry’s. Still, the flavors are fresh, and the ice cream melts faster than high-end brands.

Pricing and Value

Turkey Hill is budget-friendly, with pints at $3.28–$4 and quarts at $5–$7. This makes it cheaper than premium brands like Häagen-Dazs, which cost $5–$7 per pint. The value is a major draw.

The Late Night collection, priced at $3.99 per pint, competes with pricier brands. Customers say the generous mix-ins in flavors like Cherry Chocolate Chunk justify the cost. Deals at retailers like ShopRite add savings.

Some complain about smaller container sizes without price adjustments. Overall, Turkey Hill offers solid quality for the price. It’s ideal for those seeking variety without breaking the bank.

Pros and Cons of Turkey Hill

Turkey Hill has clear strengths and some drawbacks. Here’s a breakdown based on feedback:

• Pros:
  • Affordable prices compared to premium brands.
  • Wide variety of over 50 flavors, including new 2025 releases.
  • Smooth texture with fresh, local ingredients.
  • Available at major retailers like Walmart and Kroger.
• Cons:
  • Inconsistent mix-ins or missing ingredients in some batches.
  • Can be icy if not thawed properly.
  • Some flavors lack bold taste or sweetness.

These points help you decide if Turkey Hill fits your needs. Most find it a great value for the quality.

How Does Turkey Hill Compare?

Turkey Hill sits in the middle of the ice cream market. It’s creamier than budget brands like Great Value but less rich than Häagen-Dazs or Ben & Jerry’s. Its $3–$7 price range beats premium competitors.

Baskin-Robbins offers similar variety but loses freshness in grocery stores. Blue Bunny is comparable in price but uses artificial flavors, unlike Turkey Hill’s real cream. The Late Night collection rivals Ben & Jerry’s pints in creativity.

Turkey Hill’s strength is its balance of quality and affordability. The local sourcing and conservation efforts add appeal. It’s a solid choice for everyday indulgence.

Tips for Enjoying Turkey Hill

Let pints or quarts sit out for 5–10 minutes before scooping. This prevents iciness and makes serving easier. Pair flavors like Cookies ‘n Cream with chocolate syrup for extra decadence.

Try the Late Night pints for bold mix-ins during movie nights. Store ice cream in the freezer door for softer texture. Check Turkey Hill’s website (@turkeyhill) for seasonal flavor drops.

Buy in bulk at retailers like Giant for savings. Sample limited-edition flavors like Barbie-inspired ones early, as they sell out fast. Share quarts for family gatherings to try multiple flavors.

Where to Buy Turkey Hill

Turkey Hill is available at Walmart, Kroger, ShopRite, Food Lion, and Giant. The Late Night collection hit shelves in July 2024, with pints at $3.99. Check store locators on Turkey Hill’s website for stock.

Online, Amazon and Instacart offer delivery in some areas. The Turkey Hill Experience in Pennsylvania sells flavors and offers free samples. Mini-marts in Lancaster also carry the full range.

Availability varies by region, so confirm with retailers. Limited-edition flavors like Graham Slam require quick action. Follow @turkeyhilldairy on social media for restock alerts.

Is Turkey Hill Ice Cream Worth It?

Turkey Hill Ice Cream earns praise for its affordability and variety. Customers love flavors like Buttery Southern Pecan Pie and Cookies ‘n Cream for their creamy texture. The 2025 Late Night collection adds bold, indulgent options.

Some report issues like missing mix-ins or icy textures, but these are rare. At $3–$7, it offers great value compared to pricier brands. It’s a solid pick for budget-conscious dessert fans.

For everyday treats or special occasions, Turkey Hill delivers. Its wide flavor range and local sourcing make it appealing. Grab a pint or quart to see why it’s a freezer staple.

Summary

Turkey Hill Ice Cream remains a beloved brand in 2025, blending affordability with quality. Its 50+ flavors, including the new Late Night collection, cater to diverse tastes. Favorites like Cookies ‘n Cream and Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate Espresso earn high praise.

While some note inconsistent mix-ins or iciness, the creamy texture and local ingredients shine. Priced at $3–$7, it’s cheaper than premium competitors like Ben & Jerry’s. Turkey Hill is widely available and ideal for any dessert craving.

Whether you’re after a classic or a bold new flavor, Turkey Hill delivers value. Visit a retailer or order online to try it. It’s a reliable choice for ice cream lovers.

FAQ

What makes Turkey Hill Ice Cream stand out?
Turkey Hill uses local milk and cream for a fresh, creamy taste. Its 50+ flavors, including 2025’s Late Night collection, offer variety. The brand’s affordability sets it apart.

Are there lighter options at Turkey Hill?
Yes, Turkey Hill offers no-sugar-added and sherbet flavors, like Tropical Twist, at 150–180 calories. These suit lighter diets. Check labels for allergen details.

How much does Turkey Hill Ice Cream cost?
Pints cost $3.28–$4, and quarts are $5–$7 at retailers like Walmart. The Late Night collection is $3.99 per pint. Deals at ShopRite or Giant save more.

Where can I buy Turkey Hill Ice Cream?
Find it at Walmart, Kroger, ShopRite, and Food Lion. Online delivery is via Amazon or Instacart. The Turkey Hill Experience in Pennsylvania offers samples.

What are the best 2025 flavors?
Cookies ‘n Cream and Buttery Southern Pecan Pie top reviews for creamy texture. Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate Espresso is a bold Late Night favorite. Limited editions sell out fast.