Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. has become a beloved name in Utah’s dessert scene. Known for its hand-churned, small-batch ice cream, it offers a unique experience. This article explores what makes Blacksmith stand out based on customer reviews and expert insights.
Located in Bountiful and Millcreek, Blacksmith uses fresh, local ingredients to craft bold flavors. From classic vanilla to creative options like Honeybud, there’s something for everyone. Their commitment to quality has earned them a loyal following.
If you’re craving artisan ice cream, Blacksmith is worth a visit. We’ll dive into their top flavors, customer experiences, and what sets them apart. Let’s explore why this shop is a must-try in 2025.
Why Blacksmith Ice Cream Stands Out
Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. focuses on small-batch, hand-churned ice cream. This process ensures a rich, creamy texture that customers rave about. They prioritize fresh, local ingredients for authentic flavors.
Their menu blends nostalgic and innovative flavors. Options like Fudge Brownie and Campfire S’mores appeal to traditionalists, while Honeybud and Mango Sticky Rice excite adventurous eaters. This variety keeps customers coming back.
The shop’s welcoming atmosphere adds to its charm. Friendly staff and cozy settings make it ideal for families and dessert lovers. It’s no surprise Blacksmith has a 4.8-star rating across platforms.
Top Flavors to Try at Blacksmith
Blacksmith’s menu features a mix of always-available and seasonal flavors. Their signature offerings include Fudge Brownie, Fresh Raspberry, and Caramel Cashew. Each is crafted to highlight natural ingredients.
Seasonal flavors like Blueberry Buckle and Utah Peach shine during summer months. The Honeybud, a lavender ice cream with honey and honeycomb, is a fan favorite for its unique taste. Customers also love the Chewy Gooey Buttercake for its rich texture.
For dairy-free options, Blacksmith offers oat milk and coconut-based ice creams. Flavors like Blueberry Lemon and Royal Dutch Chocolate cater to vegan and gluten-free diets. These options ensure everyone can enjoy a scoop.
- Fudge Brownie: Rich chocolate with chewy brownie chunks.
- Honeybud: Lavender-infused with honey and honeycomb pieces.
- Fresh Raspberry: Tart and creamy with real fruit.
- Campfire S’mores: Toasty marshmallow and graham cracker swirls.
Blacksmith Ice Cream Reviews: What Customers Are Saying in 2025
Customers consistently praise Blacksmith for its creamy texture and bold flavors. Many describe it as some of the best ice cream in Utah, with a 5-star rating on Tripadvisor. Reviewers highlight the fresh ingredients and creative combinations.
The Chewy Gooey Buttercake and Milk & Honey flavors receive frequent mentions. One customer called Milk & Honey their favorite for its unique honey bits. Others love the fresh waffle cones, which add a delightful crunch.
Some note that lines can be long, especially on weekends. However, the exceptional service and quality make the wait worthwhile. Blacksmith’s welcoming staff enhances the overall experience.
Atmosphere and Customer Experience
Blacksmith’s Bountiful and Millcreek locations offer cozy, inviting vibes. The shops are clean, with a modern yet nostalgic feel. Customers enjoy the friendly, attentive staff who make every visit pleasant.
The Bountiful location, at 180 S Main St, is a popular spot for families. Its street parking and casual setting make it accessible. The Millcreek shop, at 1295 Miller Ave, is equally welcoming with a similar vibe.
Reviewers appreciate the shop’s commitment to quality. Hand-churned ice cream and fresh waffle cones elevate the experience. It’s a place where both kids and adults feel at home.
Comparison Table: Blacksmith Ice Cream Locations
| Location | Hours | Special Features |
|---|---|---|
| Bountiful | Mon-Sat, 12 PM – 10 PM | Fresh waffle cones, family-friendly vibe |
| Millcreek | Mon-Sat, 12 PM – 10 PM | Gluten-free and dairy-free options |
| Online Ordering | Available via website | Bulk orders and catering |
This table compares Blacksmith’s two locations and online services. Both shops offer similar hours and quality, but Millcreek stands out for dietary accommodations. Online ordering adds convenience for events.
Dietary Options and Inclusivity
Blacksmith caters to various dietary needs. Their gluten-free menu includes most flavors, with clear labeling for safety. Customers with celiac disease report feeling confident eating here.
Dairy-free options, like Oat Milk & Coconut-based ice creams, are vegan and nut-free. Flavors such as Blueberry Lemon and Matcha Latte are popular choices. These options make Blacksmith inclusive for all dessert lovers.
The shop’s transparency about ingredients builds trust. Their website lists allergens and flavor details, helping customers choose safely. This commitment sets them apart from other ice cream shops.
How Blacksmith Makes Their Ice Cream
Blacksmith’s “cold churn” process is a key differentiator. Unlike machine-churned ice cream, their hand-churned method creates a denser, creamier texture. This artisanal approach enhances flavor and quality.
They source local ingredients whenever possible, especially for fruit-based flavors. For example, Utah Peach uses locally grown peaches for authentic taste. This focus on freshness shines through in every scoop.
The process is labor-intensive but worth it. Small batches ensure consistency and care in every flavor. Customers notice the difference, often comparing it to homemade ice cream.
Pros and Cons of Blacksmith Ice Cream
Pros
- Creamy, hand-churned ice cream with bold flavors.
- Wide variety of gluten-free and dairy-free options.
- Friendly staff and inviting atmosphere.
- Fresh, local ingredients for authentic taste.
Cons
- Long lines during peak hours.
- Limited hours (closed Sundays).
- Seasonal flavors may not always be available.
Tips for Visiting Blacksmith Ice Cream
Visit during off-peak hours, like weekday afternoons, to avoid crowds. This ensures a quicker, more relaxed experience. Bring cash or card, as they accept both.
Try two flavors to sample Blacksmith’s range. Pair a classic like Vanilla Bean with a bold option like Honeybud. Their fresh waffle cones are a must for added texture.
Check their website for seasonal flavor updates. Ordering online for bulk or catering is great for events. Follow their social media for anniversary specials and new flavor announcements.
Where to Find Blacksmith Ice Cream
Blacksmith has two locations in Utah: Bountiful and Millcreek. The Bountiful shop is at 180 S Main St, open Monday to Saturday, 12 PM to 10 PM. The Millcreek location is at 1295 Miller Ave, with the same hours.
You can also order online for bulk or catering needs. Their website, blacksmithicecream.com, lists the full menu and ordering details. Check social media for promotions or new flavor drops.
Prices are reasonable, with scoops starting at around $4-$6. Waffle cones and specialty flavors may cost slightly more. Seasonal sales or events may offer discounts.
Summary
Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. is a standout in Utah’s dessert scene for its hand-churned, small-batch ice cream. Flavors like Honeybud, Fudge Brownie, and Fresh Raspberry earn high praise for their creamy texture and bold taste. The shop’s welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff make every visit enjoyable.
Their commitment to fresh, local ingredients and dietary inclusivity sets them apart. Gluten-free and dairy-free options ensure everyone can indulge. While lines can be long, the quality and experience are worth it.
Blacksmith’s Bountiful and Millcreek locations are must-visits for ice cream lovers. Whether you’re after a classic scoop or a unique flavor, Blacksmith delivers in 2025. Check their website for the latest menu and visit for a memorable treat.
FAQ
What are the best flavors at Blacksmith Ice Cream?
Honeybud, Fudge Brownie, and Fresh Raspberry are top picks. Customers love the creamy texture and bold, natural flavors. Seasonal options like Utah Peach are also popular.
Is Blacksmith Ice Cream safe for dietary restrictions?
Yes, they offer gluten-free and dairy-free options. Their oat milk and coconut-based flavors are vegan and nut-free. The menu clearly labels allergens for safety.
How long are the wait times at Blacksmith?
Lines can be long on weekends, especially evenings. Visiting on weekday afternoons reduces wait times. The quality and service make it worth the wait.
Where are Blacksmith Ice Cream shops located?
Blacksmith has locations in Bountiful (180 S Main St) and Millcreek (1295 Miller Ave). Both are open Monday to Saturday, 12 PM to 10 PM. Online ordering is available for bulk purchases.
Are there seasonal flavors at Blacksmith?
Yes, seasonal flavors like Blueberry Buckle and Utah Peach are offered. Check their website or social media for updates. These flavors highlight local, fresh ingredients.