Nightingale ice cream sandwiches are a delightful blend of Southern flavours and European craftsmanship. These handcrafted treats, made by a women- and veteran-owned company, elevate the classic ice cream sandwich. Their rich ice cream and fresh-baked cookies have won over dessert lovers nationwide.
Founded in 2017 in Richmond, Virginia, Nightingale combines nostalgia with sophistication. Flavors like Strawberry Shortcake and Cookie Monster draw inspiration from Southern desserts. Their growing presence in stores like Kroger and Costco makes them a must-try.
This article explores everything about Nightingale ice cream sandwiches, from their ingredients to creative serving ideas. We’ll cover their flavors, how to enjoy them, and even homemade versions. Let’s dive into this indulgent, Southern-style dessert experience.
What Is a Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwich?
Nightingale ice cream sandwiches are premium frozen treats with high-quality ice cream between two fresh-baked cookies. The ice cream, made with 14% butterfat, delivers a rich, creamy texture. Cookies are crafted to complement flavors like Banana Pudding or Chocolate Blackout.
Each sandwich weighs about 2.6 ounces, offering a satisfying portion. The “chomp” size, a smaller version, is perfect for lighter snacking. These treats balance childhood nostalgia with gourmet flair.
Nightingale’s commitment to quality sets it apart. Using real ingredients like fresh strawberries and homemade cookie crumbs, they avoid artificial flavors. Their sandwiches are a Southern twist on a classic dessert.
The Rise of Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches
Nightingale was founded by Hannah Pollack and Xavier Meers in 2017. Inspired by Southern desserts like Key Lime Pie, they aimed to create elevated ice cream sandwiches. Their handcrafted approach quickly gained attention in Richmond.
By 2025, Nightingale expanded to over 2,400 Kroger stores and select Costco locations. Social media buzz, especially around viral flavors like Cookie Monster, boosted their fame. Posts on Instagram and TikTok showcase their vibrant, indulgent appeal.
The brand’s women- and veteran-owned status resonates with consumers. Features in Fast Company and Southern Living highlight their growth. Nightingale’s blend of tradition and innovation keeps it trending.
Why Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches Are Popular
Nightingale’s appeal lies in its unique flavor profiles. Southern-inspired options like Strawberry Shortcake and Banana Pudding evoke nostalgia. The high butterfat content ensures a creamy, luxurious texture.
Their handcrafted cookies add a homemade touch, unlike mass-produced alternatives. Flavors like Cookie Monster, with cookie-crumb ice cream, are a hit with kids and adults. Seasonal offerings like Pumpkin Jack o’ Lantern keep the menu fresh.
Availability at major retailers like Kroger and Costco makes them accessible. Their quality and creativity have earned a loyal following. Nightingale delivers a dessert that feels both familiar and sophisticated.
Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwich Flavors and Ingredients
Wondering what makes up a Nightingale ice cream sandwich? Here’s a breakdown of popular flavors and their key ingredients:
- Strawberry Shortcake: Strawberry ice cream with 14% butterfat, sandwiched between brown sugar cookies, using real strawberry puree.
- Cookie Monster: Vanilla ice cream with cookie crumbs, between chocolate chip cookies, packed with nostalgic flavor.
- Banana Pudding: Banana ice cream with vanilla wafer pieces, between soft vanilla cookies, inspired by Southern tradition.
- Chocolate Blackout: Chocolate ice cream with fudge swirls, between chocolate cookies, for a rich, indulgent treat.
- Pumpkin Jack o’ Lantern: Seasonal pumpkin spice ice cream, between spiced cookies, available at select retailers.
Key ingredients include:
- Milk and Cream: High butterfat (14%) for creaminess.
- Real Fruit and Extracts: Fresh strawberries, bananas, or vanilla for authentic taste.
- Homemade Cookies: Baked fresh with flour, sugar, and butter.
These sandwiches contain allergens like milk, wheat, and sometimes nuts. Gluten-free options are not widely available. Check labels for specific dietary needs.
Nutritional Profile of Nightingale Sandwiches
A standard Nightingale ice cream sandwich (2.6 oz) has about 200–250 calories. It contains 10–14g of fat, 20–25g of sugar, and 3–5g of protein, depending on the flavor. The high butterfat content contributes to its richness.
Compared to traditional ice cream sandwiches (300+ calories), Nightingale is moderately lighter. However, its sugar and fat content make it a treat to enjoy in moderation. Seasonal flavors like Pumpkin may have slightly higher calories.
Allergens include milk, wheat, soy, and sometimes nuts or eggs. Those with dietary restrictions should check packaging. Nightingale’s focus on real ingredients adds to its indulgent appeal.
| Flavor | Calories & Fat | Key Ingredients |
|---|---|---|
| Strawberry Shortcake | 220 cal, 12g fat | Strawberry puree, brown sugar cookies |
| Cookie Monster | 230 cal, 11g fat | Cookie crumbs, chocolate chip cookies |
| Banana Pudding | 210 cal, 10g fat | Banana puree, vanilla wafer cookies |
| Chocolate Blackout | 250 cal, 14g fat | Chocolate fudge, chocolate cookies |
This table compares popular flavors, their nutrition, and key ingredients. It helps you choose based on taste or dietary needs. Always verify with store packaging for accuracy.
Benefits of Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches
Nightingale uses high-quality, real ingredients for authentic flavor. Fresh strawberry puree and homemade cookies elevate the experience. The 14% butterfat ice cream ensures a creamy, satisfying texture.
Their Southern-inspired flavors offer a unique twist on classic desserts. The brand’s women- and veteran-owned status adds a feel-good factor. Wide availability at retailers like Kroger makes them convenient.
Nightingale’s handcrafted approach appeals to those seeking premium treats. Seasonal flavors keep the lineup exciting. These sandwiches are perfect for indulgence with a nostalgic touch.
Concerns About Nightingale Sandwiches
Nightingale’s high butterfat content (14%) increases calories and fat. With 20–25g of sugar per sandwich, they’re not ideal for low-sugar diets. Moderation is key for health-conscious eaters.
Allergens like milk, wheat, and nuts may limit suitability for some. Gluten-free or vegan options are not currently offered. Cross-contamination risks may exist in production facilities.
The premium price ($6–$7 for four) is higher than standard ice cream sandwiches. Budget-conscious shoppers may hesitate. Check labels for dietary compatibility before purchasing.
How to Make Nightingale-Inspired Ice Cream Sandwiches at Home
You can recreate Nightingale’s sandwiches at home with simple ingredients. Use high-fat ice cream and freshly baked cookies for authenticity. A no-churn recipe works for beginners.
Mix heavy cream, condensed milk, and flavorings like strawberry puree or cookie crumbs. Bake soft cookies using flour, sugar, and butter. Sandwich the ice cream between cooled cookies and freeze.
Here’s a recipe for a Strawberry Shortcake-inspired sandwich:
- Ingredients: Heavy cream, sweetened condensed milk, strawberry puree, vanilla extract, and homemade brown sugar cookies.
- Steps: Whip cream, fold in condensed milk and puree, freeze for 4 hours, sandwich between cookies, and freeze again.
This recipe captures Nightingale’s creamy, nostalgic vibe. Adjust flavors to mimic Banana Pudding or Chocolate Blackout.
Creative Ways to Enjoy Nightingale Sandwiches
Nightingale ice cream sandwiches are versatile for fun desserts. Break them into pieces and mix into a milkshake for a creamy treat. Crumble over yogurt or fruit for a textured parfait.
Serve them at parties with a drizzle of chocolate or caramel sauce. Pair with coffee or hot cocoa for a cozy contrast. Use mini “chomp” sizes for bite-sized party treats.
For a Southern twist, pair Banana Pudding sandwiches with a slice of pecan pie. Their bold flavors make them perfect for creative presentations. Enjoy them as a standalone treat or dessert topping.
Tips for Choosing and Storing Nightingale Sandwiches
Choose flavors based on your preferences, like Cookie Monster for kids or Chocolate Blackout for chocolate lovers. Check labels for allergens, especially milk, wheat, or nuts. Seasonal flavors may be limited, so stock up early.
Store sandwiches at 0°F in the freezer’s back to prevent melting. Use an airtight container to avoid freezer burn. Consume within a month for the best taste and texture.
Check retailers like Kroger or Costco for deals, often $6–$7 for four. Avoid refreezing melted sandwiches to maintain quality. These tips ensure a fresh, delicious experience.
Nightingale Sandwiches for Special Diets
Nightingale sandwiches contain milk, wheat, and sometimes nuts, limiting dietary options. Gluten-free or vegan versions are not currently available. Those with allergies should check labels carefully.
For homemade versions, use gluten-free flour for cookies and dairy-free ice cream. Swap sugar for low-calorie sweeteners for reduced-sugar diets. Always verify ingredients for allergen-free sourcing.
Experiment with alternative flours like almond or coconut for unique flavors. These tweaks make homemade sandwiches inclusive. Store-bought Nightingale sandwiches are best for standard diets.
Where to Find Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches
Nightingale sandwiches are available at over 2,400 Kroger stores nationwide, priced at $6–$7 for four. Costco carries 18-packs in the Northeast, like the Cookie Monster flavor, for about $19.99. Target sells them under the Favorite Day brand.
Online platforms like Instacart offer delivery from Kroger or Target. Check Nightingale’s website for a store locator to find nearby retailers. Local grocery stores may stock seasonal flavors like Pumpkin Jack o’ Lantern.
For inspiration, browse Instagram or food blogs like Southern Living for recipes. These sources highlight Nightingale’s flavors and pairings. Explore local and online options for the best selection.
Summary
Nightingale ice cream sandwiches are a premium, Southern-inspired dessert with rich ice cream and fresh cookies. Flavors like Strawberry Shortcake and Cookie Monster blend nostalgia with gourmet quality. They’re widely available at Kroger, Costco, and Target.
This guide covered their ingredients, nutrition, and creative ways to enjoy them. While high in fat and sugar, they’re a delightful treat in moderation. Homemade recipes offer flexibility for dietary needs.
Try Nightingale sandwiches for a taste of Southern indulgence. Pair with desserts or enjoy alone for a memorable treat. These handcrafted sandwiches are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.
FAQ
What is a Nightingale ice cream sandwich?
It’s a handcrafted dessert with 14% butterfat ice cream between fresh-baked cookies. Flavors like Strawberry Shortcake and Cookie Monster use real ingredients. They’re sold at Kroger, Costco, and Target.
Are Nightingale ice cream sandwiches gluten-free?
No, they contain wheat in the cookies, making them unsuitable for gluten-free diets. Homemade versions can use gluten-free flour. Check labels for allergens like milk or nuts.
Where can I buy Nightingale ice cream sandwiches?
Find them at Kroger ($6–$7 for four), Costco (18-packs for $19.99), or Target. Online delivery is available via Instacart. Check Nightingale’s website for a store locator.
How many calories are in Nightingale sandwiches?
A 2.6 oz sandwich has 200–250 calories, with 10–14g fat and 20–25g sugar. Nutritional content varies by flavor. Check packaging for exact details.
Can I make Nightingale-style sandwiches at home?
Yes, use high-fat ice cream and bake soft cookies with flour and sugar. Sandwich the ice cream, freeze, and enjoy. Customize with flavors like strawberry or chocolate.