Double Dunker ice cream is a decadent treat that combines rich mocha flavor with cookie dough and chocolate cookie swirls. This indulgent dessert, popularized by Turkey Hill Dairy, has won over fans with its bold taste. It’s a perfect blend of creamy, crunchy, and sweet.
Introduced as a limited-edition flavor, Double Dunker became a permanent favorite due to strong demand. Its unique mix of coffee-infused ice cream and cookie mix-ins sets it apart. In 2025, it remains a go-to for dessert lovers seeking a caffeine kick.
This article explores the allure of Double Dunker ice cream, its history, ingredients, and how to enjoy it. From store-bought pints to homemade recipes, you’ll find everything you need to savor this treat. Let’s dive into the world of this mocha masterpiece!
The Origins of Double Dunker Ice Cream
Double Dunker ice cream was first introduced by Turkey Hill Dairy in 2009 as a limited-edition flavor. Its mocha base, swirled with chewy cookie dough and crunchy chocolate cookies, quickly gained a loyal following. Consumer demand led to its permanent place in Turkey Hill’s lineup by 2011.
Based in Conestoga, Pennsylvania, Turkey Hill uses milk from local farms within 75 miles. This commitment to quality ingredients enhances Double Dunker’s rich taste. The flavor draws inspiration from classic coffee and cookie pairings.
The name “Double Dunker” nods to dunking cookies in coffee, a nostalgic ritual. Its popularity reflects a love for bold, textured desserts. It’s a standout in Turkey Hill’s premium ice cream offerings.
Why Double Dunker Ice Cream Stands Out
Double Dunker’s appeal lies in its complex yet balanced flavor profile. The mocha ice cream delivers a smooth coffee-chocolate blend that’s not too bitter. Cookie dough and chocolate cookie swirls add chewy and crunchy textures.
This dessert caters to those who love coffee-flavored treats with extra indulgence. Its versatility makes it great for scoops, sundaes, or shakes. Fans praise its creamy consistency and generous mix-ins.
In 2025, Double Dunker remains a fan favorite on social media. Posts on platforms like Reddit highlight its decadent taste. It’s a treat that feels both nostalgic and modern.
Key Ingredients in Double Dunker Ice Cream
Double Dunker’s mocha base is made with milk, cream, sugar, and cocoa processed with alkali. Coffee and espresso powder add the signature mocha flavor. These ingredients create a smooth, rich foundation.
The cookie dough includes wheat flour, brown sugar, butter, and chocolate chips. Chocolate cookie swirls feature soybean oil, cocoa, and natural flavors for crunch. Stabilizers like guar gum and carrageenan ensure a creamy texture.
Some versions contain bioengineered ingredients, as noted on Turkey Hill’s website. Always check labels for allergens like milk, wheat, and soy. The ingredient list prioritizes quality and taste.
What Is Double Dunker Ice Cream?
Double Dunker ice cream is a mocha-flavored dessert from Turkey Hill Dairy. It features a creamy coffee-chocolate base swirled with chewy cookie dough and crunchy chocolate cookie pieces. The combination delivers a bold, textured treat.
Originally a limited-edition flavor in 2009, it became a permanent offering due to popularity. Available in 46–48 oz tubs, it’s sold at retailers like Kroger and Harris Teeter. Its rich taste and mix-ins make it a standout choice for coffee lovers.
Comparing Double Dunker to Similar Flavors
To help you understand Double Dunker’s appeal, here’s a comparison with two similar ice cream flavors. This table highlights key features per 2/3-cup serving.
| Brand/Flavor | Calories | Key Mix-Ins | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Turkey Hill Double Dunker | 200 | Cookie dough, chocolate cookie swirl | Mocha base, creamy texture, widely available |
| Ben & Jerry’s Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch | 280 | Toffee pieces, coffee base | Rich coffee flavor, crunchy texture |
| Häagen-Dazs Coffee Chip | 270 | Chocolate chips, coffee base | Smooth coffee taste, premium quality |
This table shows Double Dunker’s lower calorie count and unique mix-ins. Ben & Jerry’s offers a crunchier toffee texture, while Häagen-Dazs focuses on simplicity. Choose Double Dunker for its cookie-heavy profile.
Recent Products and Reviews of Double Dunker
Turkey Hill’s Double Dunker is now labeled as a “frozen dairy dessert” in some markets. This reformulation, noted in 2018 Reddit posts, uses a lighter mix with less fat and calories. Some fans were disappointed, preferring the original premium ice cream version.
Reviews from 2023 on Influenster give it a 4/5 rating, praising its smoothness and cookie mix-ins. A 2025 Reddit post called it a “new favorite” for its decadent taste, though some noted sparse cookie dough in certain batches. It’s available in 46–48 oz tubs at retailers like Kroger and Instacart.
Despite the reformulation, Double Dunker remains popular for its bold mocha flavor. Social media buzz, like a Pinterest post calling it the “best ice cream,” keeps it relevant. Check local stores or online for availability.
How to Enjoy Double Dunker Ice Cream
Scoop Double Dunker into a cone or bowl for a classic treat. Let it soften for 5–10 minutes for easier scooping. Pair with whipped cream or chocolate syrup for extra indulgence.
Try it in a milkshake by blending with milk and a banana. This enhances the mocha flavor and adds creaminess. It’s perfect for a quick dessert or afternoon pick-me-up.
For a creative twist, use it in a coffee float with hot espresso. The warm coffee melts the ice cream, creating a rich drink. Experiment with toppings like crushed cookies or caramel.
Homemade Double Dunker Ice Cream Recipe
You can recreate Double Dunker at home with simple ingredients. Start with a mocha base using 2 cups heavy cream, 1 cup whole milk, ¾ cup sugar, ¼ cup cocoa powder, and 2 tsp espresso powder. Whisk and churn in an ice cream maker for 20–30 minutes.
For mix-ins, make cookie dough with ½ cup flour, ¼ cup brown sugar, 2 tbsp butter, and ¼ cup chocolate chips. Add crushed chocolate sandwich cookies for the swirl. Fold into the churned ice cream and freeze for 4–6 hours.
This recipe mimics Turkey Hill’s flavor while letting you control ingredients. Use high-quality cocoa and coffee for the best results. Store in an airtight container to maintain freshness.
Tips for Storing and Serving Double Dunker
Keep Double Dunker at -5°F to 0°F in your freezer to maintain texture. Turkey Hill recommends using it within 3–4 weeks for optimal flavor. Seal the tub tightly after each use.
Check the package for firmness before buying. Soft or melted ice cream may affect quality. Avoid microwaving the container to prevent texture damage.
Serve in small portions to savor the rich mocha taste. Pair with a warm brownie or pie for a balanced dessert. Enjoy it mindfully to appreciate its complex flavors.
Double Dunker in 2025: Modern Twists
In 2025, some brands experiment with Double Dunker-inspired flavors. Artisanal shops add mocha ice cream with gourmet cookie dough or espresso swirls. These elevate the classic recipe with premium ingredients.
Vegan versions use coconut milk and plant-based cookie dough. These cater to dietary needs while mimicking the original taste. Check local creameries for unique takes on the flavor.
Social media trends show Double Dunker in dessert recipes, like mocha ice cream cakes. Its versatility keeps it fresh in the dessert world. Look for seasonal variations at scoop shops.
Summary
Double Dunker ice cream, a mocha-flavored treat from Turkey Hill Dairy, blends coffee-chocolate ice cream with cookie dough and chocolate cookie swirls. Introduced in 2009, it became a permanent flavor by 2011 due to fan demand. Despite a shift to a “frozen dairy dessert” formula, it remains popular in 2025, with reviews praising its creamy texture and bold taste. Available at retailers like Kroger, or easy to recreate at home, Double Dunker is a versatile dessert for coffee lovers. Enjoy it in scoops, shakes, or creative recipes for a decadent experience!
FAQ
What is Double Dunker ice cream?
Double Dunker is a mocha-flavored frozen dessert from Turkey Hill Dairy. It features cookie dough and chocolate cookie swirls for a creamy, crunchy treat. It’s a fan favorite for coffee lovers.
Why is it called a frozen dairy dessert now?
Turkey Hill reformulated Double Dunker to a lighter mix with less fat and calories. This change, noted in 2018, led to the “frozen dairy dessert” label. Some fans prefer the original premium ice cream version.
Where can I buy Double Dunker ice cream?
Find it in 46–48 oz tubs at stores like Kroger, Harris Teeter, or Instacart. Check Turkey Hill’s website for local retailers. Availability may vary by region.
Is Double Dunker ice cream gluten-free?
No, Double Dunker contains wheat in its cookie dough and chocolate cookie swirls. Check labels for allergens like milk, soy, and wheat. Those with gluten sensitivities should avoid it.
Can I make Double Dunker ice cream at home?
Yes, combine a mocha base (cream, milk, cocoa, espresso) with cookie dough and crushed chocolate cookies. Churn in an ice cream maker and freeze for 4–6 hours. Customize with vegan or low-sugar ingredients.